At this point, the people of Japan are still basking in the afterglow of 20 year-old Riyo Mori’s victory during yesterday’s Miss Universe pageant. The svelte dancer from Shizouka bested 77 other candidates from around the world for the right to be crowned by last year’s winner Zuleyka Rivera from  Puerto Rico. Interestingly, Rivera bested Riyo’s predecessor, Kurara Chibana, last year. This marks the second time that a woman from Japan will be donning the crown, but we have to travel all the way back to 1959 to recall Akiko Kojima’s triumph as the first Miss Universe from Asia.

Now more than ever though, something else other than the pomp and pageantry has grabbed headlines around the world.

Isabel Lestapier Winqvist’s of Sweden dropped out of the competition  after popular opinion in her home country showed that most people don’t think that the pageant promotes the rightful image of a modern woman. In the Miss Universe pageant, candidates parade around the catwalk in their swim suits and evening gowns as well as answer a token question for the crown. For most Swedes, this sort of treatment trivializes what a woman is and how a woman should be viewed by society.

Prior to the pageant,  a handful of protestors in downtown Mexico City also held a mock competition that featured the ‘candidates’ wearing sashes that said “Miss Sexual Health” and “Miss Marijuana”. Just like the Swedes, some Mexicans also  feel that the Miss Universe pageant misrepresents the essence of being a woman by making them fit into a specific stereotype of beauty and perfection. Even if the Miss Universe organization has partner charities, the focus is still on the candidate’s physical attributes and whatever efforts are done for those in need are reduced for a few seconds during the pageant itself.

The biggest story of them all is of course the copious booing that Miss USA Rachel Smith got after she tripped and fell during her evening gown walk. The jeering intensified when Miss USA was named into the top five over Mexico’s Rosa Maria Ojeda. Miss Universe’s co-owner Donald Trump said that the people were more likely booing US policy rather than booing Rachel Smith due to personal disdain or similar reasons.

With those controversies plaguing Miss Universe this year, is it safe to say that the legitimacy of beauty pageants was strongly contested? Is the pageant really just parading slabs of meat across the runway wearing swim wear without a pool in sight? What’s your take on this?

Related Articles



7 Responses

  1. jen_chan

    30|May|2007

    I thought Miss Japan’s answer to her last question was very simple yet deep. Miss Korea looks real pretty but her answer to her last question kinda fell short. A wallet that never runs out of money, was it…? It’s a cute answer but not Miss Universe material, I suppose.

    I felt sorry for Miss U.S.A. though she looks thinner and just dehydrated during the Miss Universe pageant compared to when she was crowned Miss U.S.A. I wonder why…?

  2. Benj Espina

    30|May|2007

    I wonder how she made it to the final 5. Come on, falling on her butt had to merit some pretty low scores, right? hehe

  3. jen_chan

    31|May|2007

    Maybe the judges thought it was very “strong” and “poised” and “brave” of her to continue on with her walk with a solid smile on her face. Kinda like past representatives who tripped and fell…

    Unfortunately, I never got to watch the beginning of the pageant. I only caught the part when the top ten were being chosen. ~:> hehe

  4. jhay

    31|May|2007

    Ever since the Miss Universe thing was conceptualized, it was never meant to promote the real essence of a woman. It was created in order to promote some darned line of underwear! hahaha

  5. hannahgrace

    01|Jun|2007

    I have no idea if they’re still relevant but it seemed to make my hubby watching the pretty girls. LOL.

  6. REX

    01|Jun|2007

    I also have no idea why she got high scores. I would give her credit for resiliently standing up after the fall. But I am not sure if it’s enough for her to be in my Top 5.

    Ganun talaga, judges’ prerogative, supposedly.

    For me, it’s not the women-degrading issue that bothers me, it’s the politics behind beauty pagaents. The Miss U, for example, is biased for Latinas. Miss World naman, for Europeans. I feel sorry for places like Turks & Caicos who keep on joining, pero impossible naman manalo.

  7. Benj Espina

    02|Jun|2007

    You seem to be an expert when it comes to these things, Rex.


Leave a reply